When I first discovered Lunch.com, I wasn’t sold. Another “social network”? Ugh, god, NO THANK YOU. Another place to house our surfeit of opinions? Even worse. Also, what was with the name? (“It makes me think of Seamless Web,” said Krystal. It makes ME think of FOOD! But then again, what is Amazon?? A river. So. Maybe I’m wrong.)
Anyway, frankly, I didn’t get it. But as I played around on the site - and thought about how I used my own blog (to express my opinions on all sorts of things and solicit feedback), I realized that actually? Um … I was wrong.
Like, really, really wrong. Lunch is still in beta (for the next two weeks), but oooooh are they on to something. [Check out Mashable’s review here.]
The biggest problem with the web, in my opinion, is that it’s like a library dumped onto a football field. Lots of amazing information, but good luck finding it. Wikipedia, Yelp & Amazon have all attempted to organize this information, specifically by harnessing the knowledge of crowds to create and maintain an elaborate database of fact (or “fact” on Wikipedia), opinion and recommendations (on Yelp & Amazon).
The problem with Wikipedia is that it’s socialist - there is one story being told at any given time, and (theoretically) no opinion. The biggest problem with Yelp & Amazon? Our opinions aren’t limited to restaurants or things we can purchase off of their site!! In fact most people (including myself, cough cough) seem to have opinions about … er … everything.
Okay, okay, so here’s the easy way to understand Lunch: it’s Wikipedia meets Yelp (but for everything).
And with much better design and organization, which I’m sure will continue to improve as they hone the site with users’ constructive criticism.
Anyway, the point is: Lunch isn’t really a social network, although they do call themselves an “online community.” I’m not an expert in these terms, but I think it’s an important distinction. I don’t need another place to connect with the marketing junkie I met at that one book party. But I wouldn’t mind knowing what he thought of the Seth Godin’s “All Marketers are Liars,” which I just finished. Or, while he’s at it, whether he liked another one of Godin’s books “Purple Cow,” which I’m considering purchasing - or Godin’s recent TED talk, up on YouTube. The marketer’s profile alone is not valuable to me. His opinions on these subjects are.
Most people have tiny bits of good information & opinions floating around in their head, just waiting to be tapped into and organized. Before the internet, you had to hope that the bit of information you needed your real-life friend just happened to have (“I’m thinking of trying out your hair stylist - what do you think?” “Well, he’s great at cuts if you have long hair, but don’t go to him for color. Try Jason over at Ted Gibson.”) If they didn’t, well … you’d just have to go it alone (pray that … interesting … “Cynthia Nixon red” was semi-permanant). And if you had an opinion to express and no one asked for it? You’d have to start your own blog! Except probably no one but your mom would read it. And let’s face it: yelling into cyberspace for your mom? Not that fulfilling.
Okay, so Lunch - unlike Facebook - is for people you DON’T already know, and wouldn’t otherwise find without what they call a “similarity network” connecting you. In other words, if you’re obsessed with shih-tzus, and I am, you might be interested in the opinions of someone who is also obsessed with shih-tzus - specifically, what does she think of the Sherpa carrier you own (and does she have a better suggestion)? Or the grooming salon at the Petco in Soho? Or the best animal shelter where you can donate my extra doggie toys?
Beyond that, what does she think of shih-tzus in general? And most importantly, what’s her favorite barking puppy shih-tzu video on YouTube?
In real life, there are no constraints to what you can have an opinion about - why should there be any online?
In other words, you can review ANYTHING - from a nail-polish to a song (not just an album!) to a speech to a cupcake.
The best part (especially for a society overwhelmed by the deluge of information online) - it’s totally, amazingly, unbelievably organized, so you don’t feel like you’re swimming in a murky sea of extraneous opinions.
Look, they’re still in beta - at least for the next two weeks - which means they don’t yet have opinions for most topics (I was the first one to review shih-tzus, Sugar Sweet Sunshine cupcakes, and Kaiya Eve pettiskirts!) But I think - if I can go out on a limb here - this site is going to be huge. Let’s put it this way: I can see my mom getting obsessed with it. And that’s pretty much the seal of mass appeal!
If you want to read my reviews or try it out, use the beta code JuliaAllison.
xo
julia
PS. This is the first of many reviews for me about new websites, products, restaurants, etc. Lunch has, among other things, inspired me to become a little more organized about the whole process. I’m really curious to know whether you think they’re accurate/helpful/etc! You can always email me - Julia@NonSociety.com. :)