Okay, I’m *STILL* trying to find the perfect place for my family - plus Meghan, Mary, CD and Britt’s girlfriend Allie - to eat tomorrow night before the theatre/ballet, etc.

Requirements:

1. Somewhere vaguely in the vicinity of the theatre district - preferably Upper West side, Central Park south, Hell’s Kitchen
2. Italian or some other fare that everyone can enjoy
3. Warm, convivial atmosphere
4. “Special” - I don’t know exactly how to describe this, but I suppose just something that you can’t find just anywhere.

HELP! I promise this is the last time I’ll ask :)